
This might come as a surprise to you, but I try to avoid publicly critiquing theatre. I often think, "What right do I have to speak ill of something so many other people believe in? I, an unemployed actor, have no right to judge the art they have spent time and money to produce for the sheer pleasure of masses. All I can do is applaud them."
And then today happened
.
Sure, it's my fault for going into the experience believing for some unclaimed reason the show was based on a Tom Hanks movie, but as soon as the lead came out in a cowboy hat and I found out it was a WESTERN, I was even LESS excited.
Then, within the first half of a 3-hour Act 1, there were so many about-to-be-dropped storylines, I was almost positive the show had been written by Ryan Murphy.
I would tell you what the show is about, but I'm not exactly sure. I can tell you it's most likely about one of the following:
1. Oil companies are BAD
2. Texas is AWESOME!
3. We did not/do not treat Mexicans very well
4. Women's rights
5. Interracial marriage
6. Alleged adultery
7. Kids who look 27 but are actually 15
8. The formation of new cattle breeds
9. Coping with death (both literal and metaphorical)
10. The importance of free and equal education opportunities
All I do know is
"Oh no! They're going to sing again!"
is not a reaction one hopes for in a musical.
I was watching a 6 person show with a cast of 18, and 20 of them had songs. 14 of them had underdeveloped storylines, and 2 of them had names I remember.
And as soon as the dead woman came back to life at the top of Act 2 for a cup of coffee and a morning chat with barely a NOD to the fact we had just watched her dead body carried off two hours ago, I KNEW I should've gotten a sandwich at intermission.
But who doesn't love a racist ghost for added conflict?
Oh, and let's dramatically drop that scrim at LEAST 40 more times for a little extra pizzazz.
I do have to give major props to my fellow Wildcats for continuing to make Northwestern University proud and for staying awake through the tepid conflict of predictable dialogue and lackluster lyrics.
How DARE you LaChiusa. You wrote a song about a TO-DO LIST. I could have gone at that score with a red pen and saved us all at
least 45 minutes of leg-crossing and hands-to-foreheads while I tried to figure out the necessity of a Mexican boy who can't hold his accent singing about checkers before you killed him off not 15 seconds later.
Yet, at the end of this epic Oregon Trail of Tears, people were on their feet applauding. I looked up at the elderly faces next to me wondering how they were OK with what had just happened. I waited to stand until the on-stage orchestra was recognized because at least THEY gave me something interesting to watch. That Reeds 3 player was GIVING. YOU. DYNAMICS.
I left with so many questions. What happened to the daughter? Why is that Mexican girl still pregnant? Wasn't there an election? Are all water towers 6 feet off the ground in Texas?
These are things I'll never know America.
So why choose to break my silence now? Why is this the musical that compelled me to critique.
Because there's a surprise straight boy my roommate and I have never met staying in our apartment for 5 days and all I can do is stay in my room and bitch.
There are not enough Christmas movies on Netflix,
TJB: Making It